| Platinum | Mario's Italian Restaurant |
| Gold | Marcos Italian American Foods |
| Silver | Fried Green Tomatoes |
| Silver | L May Eatery |
| Silver | Vinny Vanucchi's |
| Bronze | Olive Garden Italian Restaurant |
| Bronze | Shot Tower Inn |
| Top Pick | Falbo Bros Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Happy's Place |
| Top Pick | Pizza Ranch |