| Platinum | Los Aztecas |
| Gold | Lalo's |
| Silver | Fiesta Cancun Auth Mexican |
| Bronze | Adobos Mexican Grill |
| Top Pick | Ayalas Los Margaritas |
| Top Pick | Carlos O'kelly's |
| Top Pick | El Paisano's |
| Top Pick | Pancheros Mexican Grill |
| Top Pick | Salsa's Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Taco John's |