| Platinum | Foodie Garage Eatery |
| Gold | Dubuque Mining Company |
| Silver | Thumser's 19th Hole |
| Bronze | Paul's Tavern |
| Top Pick | Baraboo's On Main |
| Top Pick | Copper Kettle |
| Top Pick | Rhodey's Restaurant |
| Top Pick | The Hangry Hobo |
| Top Pick | The Otherside |
| Top Pick | West Dubuque Tap |