| Platinum | Marcos Italian American Foods |
| Gold | Mario's Italian Restaurant |
| Silver | Happy Joe's Pizza & Ice Cream Parlor |
| Silver | Town Clock Inn |
| Bronze | Knicker's Saloon |
| Top Pick | Casey's General Store |
| Top Pick | Godfather's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Magoo's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Shot Tower Inn |
| Top Pick | Your Pie |