| Platinum | Baraboo's On Main |
| Gold | Foodie Garage Eatery |
| Silver | Dubuque Mining Company |
| Bronze | Moracco Supper Club |
| Top Pick | Barrel House |
| Top Pick | Birdie Bistro |
| Top Pick | Brazen Open Kitchen + Bar |
| Top Pick | Kellys Cafe |
| Top Pick | Knockout Melts |
| Top Pick | Rhodey's Restaurant |
| Arby's |